Drama

Crime

Dancer in the Dark

Zentropa Entertainments

SVT Drama

ARTE

France 3 Cinéma

Blind Spot Pictures

Liberator Productions

Íslenska kvikmyndasamsteypan

Pain Unlimited Filmproduktion

Trust Film Svenska

Cinematograph

What Else?

ARTE France Cinéma

Film i Väst

Denmark

Finland

France

Germany

Iceland

Netherlands

Norway

Sweden

English

Björk

Catherine Deneuve

David Morse

Peter Stormare

Joel Grey

Cara Seymour

Vladica Kostic

Jean-Marc Barr

Vincent Paterson

Siobhan Fallon Hogan

Zeljko Ivanek

Udo Kier

Jens Albinus

Reathel Bean

Mette Berggreen

Lars Michael Dinesen

Katrine Falkenberg

Michael Flessas

John Randolph Jones

Noah Lazarus

Sheldon Litt

Andrew Lucre

John Martinus

Luke Reilly

T.J. Rizzo

Stellan Skarsgård

Sean-Michael Smith

Paprika Steen

Eric Voge

Nick Wolf

Timm Zimmermann

Al Agami

Alex Mouro

Alexander Arli

Allan Gyldenkærne

Ami Eklöf-Annell

Ana Christine Broström

Anders Tärneberg

Anders Thorhauge

Anders-Peter Torsleff Hansen

Ann Crosset

Anna David

Anna Norberg

Anna Rosenberg

Annette Lindholm

Anthony Ajoise Olufemi Jacob

Birgitte Skands

Bjorn Ahlander

Bo Westerholm

Bobo Eriksson

Britt Bendixen

Carl Johan De Neergaard

Carol Linda Nielsen

Claus Berenhard

Cristian Valle

Diana G.L. Watson

Ed Hickok

Edvin Karsson

Eli Stalhand

Elin Johansson

Emilie Bendz

Erik Dammann

Erik Drugge

Fredrik Börgesson

Frederik Mondrup

Marianne Bengtsson

Karoliina Heiskanen

Troels Asmussen

Caroline Sascha Cogez

Robby Müller

Avy Kaufman

Lars von Trier

Peter Grant

Molly Malene Stensgaard

Vibeke Windeløv

François Gédigier

Karl Júlíusson

Manon Rasmussen

Peter Aalbæk Jensen

Mark Bell

Sjón

John Nollet

Ursula Rödel

Cédric Gérard

Liz Miller

Lars Jönsson

Malte Forssell

Leo Pescarolo

Marianne Slot

Louize Nissen

Stig Günther

Ad Stoop

Christine Ekstrand

Morten Nybø

Frank Berger

David Koskas

Peter Hjorth

Per Streit

Mark Kenna

Harri Sipilä

Yvan Lucas

Jonas Frederiksen

Peter Garde

Andrea F. Cannistraci

Martin Högberg

Bruno Langiano

Sidsel Jensen

Anja Dahl

Julien Naudin

Sanne Gravfort

Tero Kaukomaa

Mogens Glad

Tony Grob

Charlotte Pedersen

Michelle Crane

Torleif Hauge

Anders Refn

Fridrik Thor Fridriksson

Els Vandevorst

Joakim Höglund

Kristian Eidnes Andersen

Anders Barlebo

Lene Irgens

Anja Grafers

Lisa Mustafa

Jonas Overton

Morten Jacobsen

Poul Erik Lindeborg

Finn Gjerdrum

Bent 'Niller' Nielsen

Friederik Eriksson

Jesper Lorents

Anders Jacobsen

Søren Jochumsen

Christine Bechameil

Jan Hansen

Thomas Karlsen

Paul Mason

Cecilia Hellner

Carsten Larsen

Jonas Alexander Arnby

Simone Grau Roney

Anders Lunde

Gorm Andersen

Calem Martin

Daniel Gylling

Marcel Zyskind

Jean-Robert Viallet

Jalene Murphy

Vincent Mendoza

Roger D. Faires

Joyce Nettles

Mark Berrow

Charlie Morgan

Louise Grosell

Christian Tafdrup

Dazzling Björk in this indictment against the death sentence, in tight close-ups. This film is a UFO, musical without being.

I have tremendous respect for Lars von Trier's work, and I deeply admire his courage in attempting to fuse drama with musical theater. "Dancer in the Dark" is nothing if not audacious. Unfortunately, ambition alone doesn't make a successful film, and this one fails both as a drama and as a musical.

As drama, the film stumbles on two fundamental levels. First, the handheld, shaky camera movement is completely unnecessary. Von Trier broke other Dogme 95 rules throughout this film, so why cling to this one annoying restriction? The constant jittering ruins suspension of disbelief, pulling us out of the story when we should be immersed in Selma's tragedy. Second, and more damning, there's no redeeming value to the bleak outcome. What have we learned? This is Greek tragedy without the moral lesson—the protagonist dies, and we're left with nothing but emptiness. Catharsis requires meaning, and "Dancer in the Dark" offers none.

As a musical, it fares no better. Musicals, even dark ones, require some happiness, continuity, or saving grace. The genre demands transcendence, a moment where song lifts us beyond suffering. Here, there is none. That said, Björk does a tremendous job with what she's given, and casting Joel Grey in the final courtroom musical number was absolutely brilliant, a meta-theatrical stroke that acknowledges the genre's history while subverting it.

But brilliance in moments doesn't rescue a fundamentally flawed film. "Dancer in the Dark" is an admirable failure.

CinemaSerf

You get a clue as to the slightly surreal nature of the drama right from a start that sees Björk and Catherine Deneuve doing their own amateur dramatics rehearsals of “The Sound of Music”! It turns out that the former, “Selma”, is a Czech immigrant to the USA who is suffering from a progressive blindness that she has passed on to her young son. She knows that he still has time to have corrective surgery, but she has to earn the cash to pay for that so works at a tool assembly plant and saves every cent she can. She has a small group of friends, mainly just “Kathy” (Deneuve) and “Jeff” (Peter Stormare) who would like to develop their relationship despite her obvious, though always polite, reluctance. It might be that she could have achieved her goal but for a violent altercation with “Bill” (David Morse) that sees her facing a criminal trial. Now we know what happened, and I suspect we would all be shouting the best course of action from the auditorium, but will “Selma” listen to anyone? Why? Well she has a rather unique psychological recourse when the going gets tough. She imagines that the scenario is to feature in a piece of musical theatre - and, of course, we know that the joyous lyrics and perfectly choreographed dancing will always provide for an happy ending. What chance here, though? Aside from her singing prowess, Björk also presents us with a character that is simultaneously confident and vulnerable at the same time. “Selma” is shy yet outgoing, she has a determination to see her son gets his treatment at all costs, but still has time to dream of being “Maria” (as in Julie Andrews). Now I didn't love the jarring, hand-held, photography; there is a curious frostiness to the look of the film - despite the glowing efforts from the underused Deveuve and I can’t pretend that I fully grasped quite why the dispute with “Bill” followed the path it did, but I still found I cared for this young woman and about what happened to her as her declining sight seemed to become symbolic of something more, something quite sad. It does take it’s time, but there is some humour wrapped up in this frequently quite dark analysis of not just human spirit and resilience but of 1960s small town America. Perhaps singing “My Favourite Things” does work?

I've Seen It All

AFS Presents: DANCER IN THE DARK

Original Trailer

Best Movies

Dancer in the Dark

Cast & Crew

Videos

Cast

Björk

Catherine Deneuve

David Morse

Peter Stormare

Joel Grey

Cara Seymour

Vladica Kostic

Jean-Marc Barr

Vincent Paterson

Siobhan Fallon Hogan

Box office

More Like This

Dolores Claiborne

Bring Me the Head of Alfredo Garcia

Not For, or Against (Quite the Contrary)

Short Circuit 2

Dr. Alemán

Mad Money

The Pink Panther

Crime Is Our Business